Since the release of the iPhone 2.0 firmware and the App Store, I’ve been like a kid in a candy store. At some point I’ll get around to a list of recommended apps but for now I just want to compare two music listening / online radio applications: Last.fm and Pandora.
You do, of course, have many more options – the App Store Music category has about 30 apps listed, many of them designed to help you enjoy and discover new tunes. And you always have the built-in iPod functionality of the phone which syncs with iTunes on the desktop. But Last.fm and Pandora have been around for a while as very impressive web apps so those were the first two I decided to take a look at. They have very different approaches to recommending music with lots of data and cool algorithms.
Pandora
Pandora is based on the Music Genome Project – basically, their system breaks down each song into a series of attributes. For example, Queen’s Bohemian Rhapsody has “demanding vocal performances, mild rhythmic syncopation, heavy use of vocal harmonies, a prominent rhythm piano part,” among other features. Give Pandora a song or musician and it will create a radio station of similar music. It’s really that simple.
As each song comes up you can give it a thumbs up or thumbs down and you can skip a few songs per station per hour. The iPhone interface displays the album art front and center with a button in the upper-right corner to show you why the system chose the song.
I’ve played with Pandora off and on for a while and my experience is that it does much better with stations created around one or two bands or songs than stations built on large lists of music you enjoy. Add 10 rock bands to your “Road trip with Steve 2008” station and if one of them has folk influences you’re bound to get some sleepy folk in there now and again. Give it just one band and it can get some amazing results – check out my Gorillaz station, for example.
The drawback to Pandora is that it only has very rudimentary data collection and social features. You can find other people listing to the same song on the website but user profiles are pretty sparse, and there’s no groups, message boards, etc. But if you just want to listen, and don’t want to bother with all that other stuff, Pandora provides a pretty great experience.
Last.fm
Last.fm builds radios stations for you and makes recommendations based on the listening data of thousands of other listeners, whether they’re using the Last.fm site, the mobile app, or a scrobbler plugin in their desktop MP3 player software. You can also listen to stations based around a single musician or band, but Last.fm gives you more options and better results the more you listen and participate in the social features of the site. For example, take a look at the listing for Bohemian Rhapsody – you can see top listeners, how users have tagged the song, similar songs, comments, message board posts, etc.
The user interface is actually quite similar to Pandora’s, with options to note that you love or hate a song, a skip button, album art, etc. You can see a bio of the band, similar artists, and upcoming events, which is cool in theory but I haven’t really used.
I’m a long time user of Last.fm from back in the Audioscrobbler days (check out the Geek Music group) and you definitely get more out of it the more you listen. You don’t really have to participate that much, just letting Last.fm know what you’re listing to improves recommendations and radio plays. My favorite thing about it is all the stats it collects. You can see which bands and songs you listen to most often and find out the most popular bands in Sri Lanka.
Compared to Pandora, though, the recommendations aren’t always as interesting… not bad, but I find myself pleasantly surprised more often while listening to Pandora. For comparison, listen to the Gorillaz similar artists radio station.
iPod + iTunes
You can, of course, skip online radio altogether and just use the built-in iPod functionality along with iTunes on the desktop. There’s a lot to be said for going this route – the interface is nice and usable, the iPhone holds a decent amount of music, and iTunes collects of the same listening data that makes Last.fm so cool. Also, it will work no matter how conjested the local network is and doesn’t drain the battery nearly as quickly.
But you miss out on all the social networking features and it’s a lot harder to discover new music. So I think of it more as a back-up plan… guaranteed access to some of my personal music library.
The Winner
Actually, there’s no need to pick one as the winner – they’re all available for use on your computer and your iPhone.
Have a favorite? Share your experience in the comments section.
Nice post. I agree that Pandora’s recommendations are better, and that’s a good insight about building stations around just one or two artists or songs. Just last week I found this site: http://pandorafm.real-ity.com/ which integrates Pandora and last.fm. The only feature I really care about is that is scrobbles what you listen to on Pandora to last.fm, but it’s kinda neat that you can also use the last.fm tagging and rating from the interface.
I think the UI and overall usability of the Pandora app is better then last.fm, and it has been giving me better performance on edge as well. Your right though for social networking features, Pandora is not the way to go, definitely Last.Fm wins out there. The playlists Pandora created for me are awesome. And for me, Pandora is the best.
I’ve been using both for 6 months and come to this conclusion. While Last.fm seems to have more music in it’s database and is better at recommending unknown music that you’ll actually like, the buffering times can be extremely annoying depending on your network connection. Even when connected to wifi, it often has to re-buffer mid song. Contrast Pandora which seems barely to pause when you first load it and then plays continuously through any connection with the exception of the EDGE network on occasion… and you see why I still have both on my phone.